Sugar Shaynes Gourmet Bakery Menu
Open 7 days: M-F, 6AM-8PM, Sat 7AM-5PM, Sun 8AM-4PM
Sugar Shaynes Gourmet Bakery is our in-house bakery at Luigi O’Grady’s, located in Pearl River, Rockland County NY. It is run by Michelle Worob, who took over Sweet Sensations' line of cupcakes and baked goods. Michelle bakes fresh cakes and pies, cookies, brownies, cupcakes and other sweet treats daily. There is always a selection of sweet treats available for last-minute pickup at Luigi O’Grady’s Deli. Your custom orders are welcome as well! Please give us a call at 845-735-9110 and allow 4 days to have your treats ready for you!
Gourmet Cupcakes
Red Velvet, Oreo, Carrot, Lemon, Vanilla/Vanilla, Vanilla/Chocolate, Vanilla/Fudge, Chocolate/Vanilla, Chocolate/Chocolate, Chocolate Ganache, S'mores, Rocky Road, Peanut Butter, Coconut, Holiday-Themed Decorations
$2.00 each
Regular Size for Special order
$2.00 each
$10 per package
Pre-packaged 6 packs (all one flavor)
$10 per package
$4.50 each
Jumbo Cupcakes
$4.50 each
Cupcake Cakes
Decorated just like a sheet cake with flowers and writing!
$2 per cupcake.
Made with regular-size cupcakes
$2 per cupcake.
Multiples of 6 cupcakes (minimum 24, 30, 36, etc).
Choose up to 2 flavors of cake
Chocolate, Yellow, Carrot, Red Velvet
One Frosting covers the whole cake
Buttercream, Cream Cheese
Sheet Cakes
$35
1/4 Sheet (serves 15-25)
$35
$60
1/2 Sheet (serves 25-40)
$60
$80
3/4 Sheet (serves 45-65)
$80
$110
Full Sheet (serves 70-80)
$110
Choose your cake flavor:
Yellow, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Carrot
Bavarian Cream, Chocolate Pudding, Vanilla Pudding, Chocolate Mousse, Cannoli (extra charge of $10-25 depending on size)
Choose your filling:
Bavarian Cream, Chocolate Pudding, Vanilla Pudding, Chocolate Mousse, Cannoli (extra charge of $10-25 depending on size)
Choose your icing:
Vanilla or Choclate Buttercream, Whip Cream, Cream Cheese Frosting
$5 to $25 depending on cake size)
Add fresh fruit (additional charge of
Strawberries, Bananas
$5 to $25 depending on cake size)
$20.00 additional charge
Add a scanned picture
$20.00 additional charge
Crumb Cakes
Available in Plain, Blueberry, Apple or Marble
Plain $40
/
Flavored $60
1/2 Sheet (serves 30-40)
Plain $40
/
Flavored $60
Plain $50
/
Flavored $90
Full Sheet (serves 60-80)
Plain $50
/
Flavored $90
Iced Brownies
Fudge Sprinkles, Fudge Walnuts, Oreo, S'Mores, Peanut Butter, Rocky Road. A selection always available at the store or order by the 1/2 sheet:
$40
Fudge/Sprinkles
$40
$55
Fancier Flavors
$55
Homemade Black & White Cookies
Large Individual and Mini 6 Packs are always available at the store. Order our Mini B&W Cookie Platters:
$30
24 Cookies
$30
$60
48 Cookies
$60
Homemade Linzer Tarts (Raspberry)
Large Individual and Mini 6 Packs are always available at the store. Order our Mini Linzer Tart Platters:
$35
18 Cookies
$35
$65
36 Cookies
$65
Typically, we ask for 4 days notice on special orders! Please give us a call at 845-735-9110 or drop by the store! We look forward to helping you cater your next party with our guest-pleasing desserts!